Realism in loli hentai

cunny poster

varishangout.com
Regular
Re-post from /b/ https://zzzchan.xyz/b/thread/13115.html

https://archive.md/cgNH8 / https://anonfiles.com/r1E9R0E7pa/Small_Project_7z


I started this small project to satisfy my own autism. This is the result of 4 straight weeks of on average reading 43+ loli hentai galleries a day, followed by nearly 2 more weeks of miscellaneous tasks. These lists were collected from over 1200 lolicon works, over 430 lolicon artists, and over 280 translators. The goal of this small project was initially just to create a mass of crops from lolicon hentai where there was a significant textual focus on the loli being or appearing to be a child, or similar such explicit mention of any sexual agents' attraction being to that of children and compare their number to a total count of lolicon hentai. Autism quickly took over however, and I continued adding more tasks. I decided to loosely separate the two large categories into three subcategories each depending on the level of realism, to see how much loli I consume relative to non-loli I needed to count up the total of average non-loli hentai I consumed, to make lists of artists and translators to see which had the greatest effect on whether a work contained the aforementioned textual focus, to make a collage of titles with textual focus, to make a list of titles using cunny, to do some cursory research into certain things that stood out to me, and various other minor things. I cannot say for certain what all of these numbers imply about my loli consumption habits or lolicon as a whole, but I will comment on trends and outliers. At the end of this paragraph I will put all images and text files into an archive and upload it to anonfiles, which may include some information referenced that was not posted. First up, disclosure of my flawed methodology, then the numbers and comments, and finally some miscellaneous stuff I found along the way. Then I'll dump every single crop in the thread to give a sense of their quantity, so that people may save those they like which stand out to them without going through the whole archive, and so that people who won't bother with the archive may see them.
https://anonfiles.com/r1E9R0E7pa/Small_Project_7z



Methodology
What qualifies as an instance of textual focus?
Words and phrases qualifying for textual focus are pedo, pedophile, little girl, underage, gradeschooler, elementary school, child, prepubescent, immature/childish/underdeveloped [body part], JS (slang for gradeschooler), JC (slang for middleschooler), et cetera. "Child" and "little girl" must be used in a way that is not how an eldery person or parent could refer to adults. Title text can qualify, as in Rustle's Little Girl series, but does not count multiple times if the title reappears elsewhere such as the credits. As this is about lolicon, such things referring specifically to shotas do not qualify. "Brat/bratty" and "Young girl" do not qualify due to likely common use to refer to JKs/highschoolers. Some fairly explicit though more indirect combinations of statements may qualify, such as references to how long ago a sexual act took place with a character directly implying her age at the time of lewding. Immature/childish/underdevopled [body part] was not initially counted as it ought have been in retrospect, so the count of works with significant textual focus should be considered somewhat of an underestimation.

What qualifies a work for significant textual focus?
Requirements for significant textual focus, also referred to as With Word or WW, are at least three instances of textual focus. Even if a single use is extremely explicit and severe, such as in Lady Yupiel's Servant where the MC is called a pedo by lolibaba Yupiel, it will not qualify. Though some severe instance may still be cropped and placed in Honorable Mentions.

Extra things may be thrown in the crops for fun, such as jokes and use of the word cunny. These do not contribute to instances of textual focus.


Why the separation of works into levels of realism?
A lack of explicit text alone is not proof a work doesn't contain a focus on a loli being or appearing to be a child, text crops are just used as the primary objective because explicit visual representation is more effective at communicating the contents. For that reason, it felt more honest to also loosely categorize stories based on their relative levels of realism. Even then being categorized as Fantasy and not having a strong textual focus on the age/appearance of age of the girl doesn't indicate there is no focus on it, such as in works like the second chapter of Mad Scientist Ootori, where the the lolicon has Ootori dress in a middle schooler outfit, randoseru and all, purely for the sake of fetishization on both the artist's and the MC's part. But this was the best I felt I could do. The lines drawn between these categorizations may at times be thin, and even subject to change if anyone brings up particularly good examples of miscategorizations and these examples pile up to a significant number.

What qualifies as Fantasy?
The vast majority of things qualifying works for the Fantasy category are those that break the laws of physics. Short comical chibi gags and other similar minor gags do not count towards physics breaking. Lolibaba is a Fantasy element and legal loli, like lolibaba, is considered a Fantasy element even if all else is normal, such as in Toradora! Porn Book. Major world differences like silly erotic new laws and other societal scale changes are considered a strong Fantasy element. If the setting is Fantasy, the work qualifies even if no physics breaking shenanigans take place, such as many Touhou and Prisma Illya doujinshi. Some works with no physics breaking fantasy or sci-fi elements can still qualify as Fantasy if something ridiculously improbable enough happens, such as the practically magically convenient talking parrot in Blue Bird of Good Fortune. "It was all a dream" is a fantasy element if the majority of lewd in the story is contained to the dream.

'What qualifies as Very Unrealistic?
Generally outrageous and highly improbable situations or characters acting wildly inconsistent, unreasonable, or irrational. Minor comic relief panels with exaggerated or chibi artstyle do not alone qualify as Very Unrealistic, but constant ones may. Extreme perversion and some level of precociousness will not necessarily qualify something as Very Unrealistic, because after all, precocious perverted girls are at the core of lolita complex and are not wholly unrealistic. I myself was sexually precocious and was doing very sexual things around 8 or 9, before I could even get an erection. No, I will not talk about it further.

If a continuous story has one entry with strong fantasy or unrealistic elements, all subsequent entries must categorized as equally or more unrealistic, regardless of realism, due to having an unrealistic or fantasy premise, such as Mitemite Ecchi where a loli is left in charge of a bath house. The only exception to this rule if an entry qualifies for fantasy due to the majority of it being dream, only to return to a story without strong fantasy elements in following entries, such as Tsuttsu's Welcome to the 2-2 Pee Soapland.

I'm not too familiar with the plots and settings of [email protected] games, so I've decided to qualify them as Very Unrealistic at minimum.

What qualifies as Least Unrealistic?
Generally situations have a decent level of plausibility. Characters are mostly consistent and rational. Rational of course, does not equate to intelligent. I've decided to label this category as Least Unrealistic rather than most realistic, because I know true realism is rarely ever reached in most mediums and often debatable. These works are just the relatively most realistic, and within this category can very from extremely realistic to simply not very unrealistic.
What does and doesn't count as loli?
With little exception, things counted as loli are all tagged as loli. Only 2 works not tagged as loli were counted, due to being multi-work series where the middle entries were mis-tagged. Things not counted as loli are often borderline lolis, usually tagged with the low_lolicon or oppai_loli tags. These will often be referred to as LL for Low Lolicon content. Clear oppai loli is always disqualified unless a regular loli is also present. I was strict with the Low Lolicon disqualifier early on, but relaxed my enforcement of it before I was halfway through.

What is disqualified from the lists for other reasons?
Imagesets, western galleries, misc, and non-h are disqualified. Galleries that are essentially imagesets, such as Keta's doujinshi, will be counted as such and disqualified.

A gallery beyond 100 pages will be overlooked due to length for the sake of time and the simplicity of avoiding tanks and anthologies with a wide variety of artists and translators to separated out. A gallery with 10 or fewer pages will be overlooked due to length for the sake of focusing on the average lolicon story, which is around 20 pages. Non-traditional manga/doujinshi that are digital only may be disqualified as small as well even above 10 pages, should they have sparse content per page such as Digital Broadcasting Girl. Works that have a significant number of pages but are comprised of multiple extremely short stories will be disqualified as small, such as Rustle's Lolicon Special 2, where most of the stories are 1 page and the longest story is 8 pages.

Why do some longer galleries count multiple times?
Multiple works in a single upload under 100 pages, such as Quzilax's Loli to Bokurano made up of various stories or Maeshima Ryo's Masturbating made up of multiple chapters of the same story, may be broken up and thus duplicated, even into different categories if they're separate stories. Appended to the end of the gallery name will be PART [X] and possibly the individual story's title. These extra works add to the total count and have the same restrictions on minimum length as standalone galleries. Extremely short Chapter "0" prologues at the beginning of a continuous story within one gallery will be counted as part of the PART 1 of that series along with the Chapter 1, but if not continuous will not be counted at all.

The above two bold points are rules that apply to the total count of non-loli galleries as well.


Arist list rules
If multiple artists are listed, the first artist will be used if it is not clear which artist did the majority of the work.

Translator list rules
Works listed as translated in collaboration by multiple groups will count once each for all those groups, however if multiple translators / groups / editors collaborate and all galleries translated by those groups contain only the same collaborators grouped together, they will be listed together as a single group with a "+" between them. If it's not explicitly clear who translated a work, it will be filed under Anonymous. If a translator is listed as Anon/Anonymous or is unknown, but the uploader admits to having worked on the translation, the uploader will be listed as the translation group. Translators and translation groups include any credits to official translators, such as in Rustle's Fondle Lollipop #3. If an official translation lists no group, the translator group will be the circle. If there is no circle or translator, it will be OFFICIAL. Translation groups with acronyms will only have the full name of the group listed if there are galleries using it in the title.

G Just G lists himself in the space for translation groups, but he's just a commissioner and his commissions have the actual translators listed, so they will be used instead.

Rules applying to both artist and translator lists
Galleries for which the artist or translator is not listed in the title but which either can be found in the tags or gallery will have the artist/translator group added in its proper place in the lists of galleries. As not all gallery titles follow proper formatting for artists and translators, there may be some of both listed that don't actually exist, or multiple entries for a single artist/translator with multiple pseudonyms. All works that don't have an artist or translator listed in the correct place and not found within the gallery at all will be tallied under Anonymous.



Numbers
Count of galleries, artists, and translators within each category.
Galleries
341 Fantasy
162 Very Unrealistic
268 Least Unrealistic
76 Fantasy WW
152 Very Unrealistic WW
217 Least Unrealistic WW

As expected, the amount with a textual focus rose going from fantasy to realism. Those without textual focus beat those with textual focus in all categories, though just barely in Very Unrealistic.

417 Fantasy Total
314 Very Unrealistic Total
485 Least Unrealistic Total

Stories tended to lean on way or the other in terms of realism and fantasy, leaving the middle with a shorter stick, but Least Unrealistic beat out Fantasy by decent chunk.

771 Wordless
445 WW
1216 Loli Total

1651 Non-loli Total
150 Low loli
2867 Total withholding Low Loli
3017 Final Total
Original counts Loli/Not Loli/Total 1602/1734/3336 48.00% Loli

I felt it important to include things disqualified for Low Lolicon content as they could still be counted as average galleries unlike those excluded for other reasons, and could count for, against, or neutrally in relation to the Loli Total count.

Artists
197 Fantasy
113 Very Unrealistic
123 Least Unrealistic
63 Fantasy WW
84 Very Unrealistic WW
110 Least Unrealistic WW

234 Fantasy Total
169 Very Unrealistic Total
191 Least Unrealistic Total

345 Wordless
179 WW
432 Total

Translators / Groups / Editors
143+ Fantasy
71+ Very Unrealistic
98+ Least Unrealistic
43+ Fantasy WW
52+ Very Unrealistic WW
73+ Least Unrealistic WW

226+ Wordless
122+ WW
286+ Total

Categories for totals of Fantasy, Very Unrealistic, and Least Unrealistic regardless of textual focus were not put together for translators as it felt irrelevant. They are not creating the plot, only choosing the words. While they choices may have an effect on realism, it is not as strong as the mangakas unless they are blatantly and viciously mistranslating, i.e. not really translating at all. I'm disappointed in any of these lists that are under 100, as I feel a larger pools would give much more useful data.

Percentages
Percentages of galleries, artists, and translators out of the totals of their respective lists. First three gallery categories are special, all others will be taken out of the Loli Total.

Galleries
40.30% Loli Total vs Final Total
42.41% Loli Total vs Total withholding Low Loli
45.28% Loli + Low Loli vs Final Total

As you can see, a significant portion of the average hentai I read, 40-45%, is loli. I believe that ratio will continue to rise over time for me, possibly reaching as high as 60%. There are 70,323 English Manga/Doujinshi galleries on the panda, 13,122 are tagged as lolicon. That's 18.67%, so I am very partial to loli. This also means I've read over 10% of all English loli Manga/Doujinshi on the panda and used nearly 10% of it for these lists.

28.04% Fantasy
13.32% Very Unrealistic
22.04% Least Unrealistic
06.25% Fantasy WW
12.50% Very Unrealistic WW
17.85% Least Unrealistic WW

34.29% Fantasy Total
25.82% Very Unrealistic Total
39.88% Least Unrealistic Total

63.40% Wordless
36.60% WW

Lolicon galleries were over 1/3 those with a significant textual focus.

Artists
45.60% Fantasy
26.16% Very Unrealistic
28.47% Least Unrealistic
14.58% Fantasy WW
19.44% Very Unrealistic WW
25.46% Least Unrealistic WW

54.17% Fantasy Total
39.12% Very Unrealistic Total
44.21% Least Unrealistic Total

79.86% Wordless
41.44% WW

Translators / Groups / Editors
50.00% Fantasy
24.82% Very Unrealistic
34.27% Least Unrealistic
15.03% Fantasy WW
18.18% Very Unrealistic WW
25.52% Least Unrealistic WW

79.02% Wordless
42.66% WW

Artist and translator percentages are roughly a reflection of the galleries in each category, but add up to over 100% due to individual artists and translators working on galleries from multiple categories.
Top Artists
Top producing artists in their respective categories and the percentages of each category contributed by them followed by how much of each category's artists they make up. Each category will have approximately 10 entries with more or fewer depending on ties. If ties result in the same difference from 10 being chosen whether under or above 10, above 10 will be chosen. Each category will list the percent contributed by its top top producing artist(s) and any other high outliers.

Fantasy top 11/197
12 Musouduki
8 Yukino Minato
7 BeNantoka
7 Hoshino Fuuta
6 LEE
6 Rustle
5 Bosshi
5 Ro
5 Satsuki Itsuka
5 YASSY
5 yam
20.82% of works listed are produced by 5.58% of artists
03.52% were produced by Musouduki


Very Unrealistic top 12/113
6 Tanabe Kyou
6 Hoshino Fuuta
4 Tsuttsu
4 Yamazaki Kana
4 Ogu
3 Ryoumoto Hatsumi
3 Himeno Mikan
3 Henreader
3 Fujisaka Lyric
3 Inuboshi
3 SOFTCHARM
3 Hashibiro Kou
27.78% of works listed are produced by 10.62% of artists
03.70% were produced by Tanabe kyou and Hoshino Futa each


Least Unrealistic top 11/123
15 Rustle
9 OKINA
8 Arekusa Mahone
8 Maka Fushigi
8 Hoshino Fuuta
8 Tsubaki Jushirou
7 Sakurafubuki Nel
7 Tanaka-Ex
7 Hidari Kagetora
6 Higashiyama Show
6 LEE
33.21% of works listed are produced by 8.94% of artists
05.60% were produced by Rustle.

Rustle appears to be a special outlier here, the only single artist breaking over 5% in a particular category. However Rustle is also the top artist, producing 26 works, 5 more than 2nd place. So I may just really like Rustle, or it may be that Rustle is more prolific than the average loli artist. Either way, 17 of his works lean hard towards realism 2 from Least Unrealistic WW, more than half of those he contributed to these lists.

Fantasy WW top 12/63
3 Sakurafubuki Nel
2 BeNantoka
2 Nanashi 774
2 Nakamura Kanko
2 Himeno Mikan
2 Quzilax
2 Typehatena
2 Saeki Tatsuya
2 OGU
2 Miyasaka Takaji
2 Minion
2 Sugoi Hi
32.89% of works listed are produced by 19.05% of artists
03.95% were produced by Sakurafubuki Nel


Very Unrealistic WW top 7/84
7 Yone Kinji
6 Ogu
5 BeNantoka
5 Maeshima Ryou
5 Kiya Shii
4 Yam
4 Kuromotokun
23.68% of works listed are produced by 8.33% of artists
04.61% were produced by Yone Kinji


Least Unrealistic WW top 10/110
9 Satuyo
9 Onizuka Naoshi
8 Kiya Shii
7 Chiguchi Miri
7 Yawaraka Midori
6 Airandou
5 Noise
5 Quzilax
5 Arekusa Mahone
5 Kinomoto Anzu
30.41% of works listed are produced by 9.09% of artists
04.15% were produced by Satuyo and Onizuka Naoshi each


Fantasy ALL top 8/234
13 Musouduki
9 BeNantoka
8 Yukino Minato
7 Rustle
7 Hoshino Fuuta
6 yam
6 Satsuki Itsuka
6 LEE
14.87% of works listed are produced by 3.42% of artists
03.12% were produced by Musouduki


Very Unrealistic ALL top 10/169
10 Ogu
7 Yone Kinji
7 Tanabe Kyou
7 Kiya Shii
6 Maeshima Ryou
6 Hoshino Fuuta
6 Himeno Mikan
6 Fujisaka Lyric
5 Hashibiro Kou
5 BeNantoka
20.70% of works listed are produced by 5.92% of artists
03.18% were produced by Ogu


Least Unrealistic ALL top 11/191
17 Rustle
15 Onizuka Naoshi
13 Arekusa Mahone
10 Satuyo
10 Sakurafubuki Nel
10 OKINA
9 Maka Fushigi
8 Tsubaki Jushirou
8 Kiya Shii
8 Hoshino Fuuta
8 Chiguchi Miri
23.92% of works listed are produced by 5.76% of artists
03.51% were produced by Rustle


Wordless top 10/345
23 Rustle
21 Hoshino Fuuta
13 Yukino Minato
12 LEE
12 Arekusa Mahone
12 Musouduki
11 Maka Fushigi
10 OKINA
10 Tanabe Kyou
10 Tsubaki Jushirou
17.38% of works listed are produced by 2.90% of artists
02.98% were produced by Rustle
02.72% were produced by Hoshino Fuuta
05.71% were produced by these top two outliers, 0.58% of artists


WW top 12/179
13 Kiya Shii
11 Satuyo
9 Onizuka Naoshi
9 Chiguchi Miri
9 Yawaraka Midori
9 Maeshima Ryou
9 BeNantoka
8 Airandou
8 Fuyuno Mikan
8 Sakurafubuki Nel
8 Ogu
8 Yone Kinji
24.49% of works listed are produced by 6.70% of artists
02.92% were produced by Kiya Shii


ALL top 11/432
26 Rustle
21 Hoshino Fuuta
18 BeNantoka
18 Arekusa Mahone
17 Sakurafubuki Nel
15 Onizuka Naoshi
15 Ogu
15 Kiya Shii
14 Yukino Minato
14 Tanabe Kyou
14 Musouduki
15.37% of works listed are produced by 2.55% of artists
02.14% were produced by Rustle

Top Translators
Top translators in their respective categories and the percentages of each category contributed by them, followed by how much of each category's translators they make up. Each category will have approximately 10 entries with more or fewer depending on ties. If ties result in the same difference from 10 being chosen whether under or above 10, above 10 will be chosen. Each category will list the percent contributed by its top top translator(s) and any other high outliers. Anonymous will be excluded from top lists. Because some galleries were worked on by multiple credited translators, groups, or editors and many were translated anonymously, percentages of works are an overestimation and percentages of translators are an underestimation.

Fantasy top 11/143+
18 CapableScoutMan
18 Bigk40k
16 ATF
13 LWB
10 biribiri
9 Hennojin
9 SaHa
8 5 a.m.
7 Mant
7 DesuDesu
7 BSN
35.78% of works listed were translated by 7.69% of translators
05.27% were by CapableScoutMan and Bigk40k each


Very Unrealistic top 10/71+
13 LWB
12 Mistvern
12 ATF
11 5 a.m.
5 biribiri
5 Hennojin
5 LoliLoli Hunters
4 Team Vanilla / TV
4 SaHa
4 Doki Fansubs
45.30% of works listed were translated by 14.08% of translators
08.02% were by LWB


Least Unrealistic top 10/98+
28 5 a.m.
18 ATF
16 Team Vanilla / TV
13 Hennojin
11 Mistvern
6 bfrost
6 Hayama Kotono
6 LWB
5 biribiri
5 QB-tl.com / QB Translations
42.54% of works listed were translated by 10.20% of translators
10.45% were by 5 a.m.


Fantasy WW top 9/43+
6 Mistvern
6 ATF
4 S.T.A.L.K.E.R.
4 LWB
4 CapableScoutMan
4 Bigk40k
3 desudesu
3 Mongolfier
3 5 a.m.
48.68% of works listed were translated by 20.93% of translators
07.89% were by Mistvern and ATF each


Very Unrealistic WW top 10/52+
27 Mistvern
24 5 a.m.
14 ATF
7 LWB
5 Chastity Dreamer Schmo / Chastity Dreamers
3 biribiri
3 Tiramisu
3 TLRF
3 CGrascal
3 Bigk40k
60.53% of works listed were translated by 19.23% of translators
17.76% were by Mistvern
15.79% were by 5 a.m.
09.21% were by ATF
42.76% were by these top three outliers, 5.77% of translators


Least Unrealistic WW top 9/73+
31 Mistvern
21 ATF
20 5 a.m.
16 Doki Fansubs
13 biribiri
10 Bigk40k
7 SquigglesJP
6 Shippoyasha
5 TV / Team Vanilla
59.45% of works listed were translated by 12.33% of translators
14.29% were by Mistvern


Wordless top 10/226+
47 5 a.m.
46 ATF
32 LWB
27 Mistvern
27 Hennojin
23 Team Vanilla / TV
20 biribiri
18 CapableScoutMan
18 Bigk40k
15 SaHa
35.41% of works listed were translated by 4.42% of translators
06.10% were by 5 a.m.
05.97% were by ATF
12.06% were by these top two outliers, 0.88% of translators


WW top 11/122+
64 Mistvern
47 5 a.m.
41 ATF
18 biribiri
17 Doki Fansubs
17 Bigk40k
11 LWB
9 Shippoyasha
7 SquigglesJP
6 TV / Team Vanilla
6 Chastity Dreamer Schmo / Chastity Dreamers
54.61% of works listed were translated by 9.02% of translators
14.38% were by Mistvern
10.56% were by 5 a.m.
09.21% were by ATF
34.16% were by these top three outliers, 2.46% of translators

As you can see, the spread of translators across galleries without textual focus is more even than those with textual focus. A max outlier gap of 14 vs 23, and WW has more outliers despite less total translators. The average of those outliers for WW, 50.67 is greater than the average for those without textual focus, 46.5, despite there being nearly twice as many galleries without textual focus. Over a third of galleries with textual focus were made by only three translation groups. This suggests a portion of galleries by these groups may have had textual focus more on the part of the these translators than on the part of the mangaka.

ALL top 10/286+
94 5 a.m.
91 Mistvern
87 ATF
43 LWB
38 biribiri
35 Bigk40k
29 Team Vanilla / TV
29 Hennojin
23 Doki Fansubs
22 CapableScoutMan
40.38% of works listed were translated by 3.50% of translators
07.73% were by 5 a.m.
07.48% were by Mistvern
07.15% were by ATF
22.37% were by these top three outliers, 1.05% of translators

In regards to overall total galleries, these same three translations groups only account for over a 5th of translations, a significant step down from their 1/3 in WW. However, 5 a.m. has a perfect 50/50 split as to galleries with and without a textual focus, making it unlikely that their bias in word choice had much abnormal effect on the results. Similarly ATF actually translated slightly more works without textual focus than with. That leaves only Mistvern as a true outlier, being the top contributing translator/group in every single WW category save for Fantasy WW, which they tied for. Mistvern had 70% of translations include a textual focus, 14% of all those in WW. If one was to assume the absolute worst of this group, that there was blatant bias in word choice against the actual wording used by Mangaka, and discount these 64 galleries from WW and into Wordless instead, the percentage of galleries in WW would shift from 36.60% to 31.33%, a shift of 5.27% from just over a third to just under a third, but an error in over 5% of the total works categorized.

Overall, such word bias in favor of textual focus is likely not rampant given nearly 95% of galleries don't appear to come from small prolific groups suspicious of this word bias, but from a wide variety of translators, most of the biggest of which appear to be unbiased towards or lean against textual focus. Something to note though is that looking as some titles such as those from the My Teacher Is a Perverted Pedophile Scumbag series, ATF is known to translate "lolicon" as "pedophile" on multiple occasions.
Top Densities
Stories with a minimum of 20 instances of textual focus.

44 My First Job
40 Loli Friends
38 Loli-harem Protagonist
32 I'll Take Care of You
28 First-Time at a Love Hotel
27 Middle-Aged Men Who Live Earnestly Deserve a Little Pay-Off Right?
23 Aina-chan is a Raw Fuck JP IDOL
22 You Stood There With The Likeness of a Devil
21 Week of European Fairy
20 Ujiie-san-chi no Katei Teinai Shoubai
20 The Curious Elementary School Bitch!
20 Grade-schooler sluts are the best!!!

I really thought the highly realistic and dark Loli Friends, Quzilax's second most infamous story to my knowledge, would take first place, but found My First Job by Kudou Hisashi shortly after. I was not initially keeping an eye out for particularly dense galleries, but I don't think I had missed any by the time I began this list either.


Titles With Textual Focus
These galleries are placed in a collage posted in the OP, downscaled. The full size collage is in the archive file. Galleries can qualify for the title collage regardless of whether they are in the WW category. Galleries only qualify if the title of the work contains textual focus, not the title of the tank or magazine, so things like Puni Pedo galleries do not count. In the case of there being no English text to crop, the English title in the gallery title is capped and placed below the Japanese text. In the further case of no English title existing even in the gallery title, a rudimentary rough translation via machine translation may be placed below instead, or the title of a work with an extremely similar title may be referenced, such as in the Chichi no Aijin series.
6 Fantasy
0 Very Unrealistic
8 Least Unrealistic
11 Fantasy WW
21 Very Unrealistic WW
26 Least Unrealistic WW

Aside from the anomaly of Very Unrealistic having 0 titles, the list of titles with textual focus follows the expected trend of increasing cases from those without significant textual focus to those with significant textual focus, and from fantasy to realism.

Cunny
Galleries that used the somewhat controversial term "cunny" at least once. Those that didn't qualify for a textual focus crop but still have a crop in Honorable Mentions will be listed under Honorable Mentions with a note about any other category they may fall in. Cunny does not count toward the minimum three instance requirement for textual focus. Since there are so few, this list of galleries will be posted directly instead of only available in the archive.

Fantasy - 2
[Satsuki Itsuka] Chijo 〇-sai Kyou no Deshi! | Apprentice to a _ Year-Old Slut! (Byuu Byuu Bitch) [English] {Risette}
[Serizawa Yuuji] Rhapsody (Banana Shake) [English] =TV=

Fantasy WW - 4
[Satsuki Itsuka] Kokusei Chousa (Census) [English] [Decensored]
[Okada Kou] Chu-Gakusei Nikki Ch. 4, 8-9 [English] [BlindEye]
(C94) [Menteisho (Menteiyakuna)] Shikyuu Shounin Mesugakis [English] [Xood]
(C96) [micro page (Kuromotokun)] JC Saimin de Seikyouiku + JC no Omake [English] [Xood]

Very Unrealistic WW - 8
[Akazawa RED] CosPako! Shiro-chan no Baai | Cosplay Hump! Shiro-chan's case (Comic LO 2015-12) [English] {5 a.m.}
[The Dungeon In Yarn (Yone Kinji)] Rape ni Akogareteru Onnanoko ga Yamagoya ni Hitori de Itara...... | If A Rape Loving Girl is Alone in a Mountain Hut [English] [Shippoyasha] [Digital]
[Airandou] Namaiki Luna-chan (COMIC LO 2018-11) [English] [Xood] [Digital]
[Kereno Teikoku (Kereno)] Jitsu Musume ga Shougakusei Idol Yusa Kozue-chan 11-sai | My Actual Daughter Is 11 Year Old, Grade-Schooler Idol, Yusa Kozue (THE [email protected] CINDERELLA GIRLS) [English] [Galuxi]
[Kereno Teikoku (Kereno)] Ryuzaki Kaoru Ninshin Botebara Bunny Cos Sex Shussan | Childbirthing Bunny Cosplay Sex with Super Preggo Kaoru Ryuzaki (THE [email protected] CINDERELLA GIRLS) [English] [cutegyaruTL]
[Kereno Teikoku (Kereno)] Shougakusei to Sex Shite Aka-chan Unde Hoshii Sajo Yukimi-chan 10-sai | I Want to Fuck 10-Year-Old Elementary Schooler Yukimi Sajo and for Her to Give Birth (THE [email protected] CINDERELLA GIRLS) [English] [cutegyaruTL] [Digital]
[The Dungeon In Yarn (Yone Kinji)] Aina-chan wa Nama Honban JP Idol | Aina-chan is a Raw Fuck JP IDOL [English] [Chastity Dreamer Schmo] [Digital]
[Himeno Mikan] Muzu-Imo! | Horny Little Sister! (COMIC LO 2015-09) [English] {Mistvern}

Least Unrealistic WW - 6
[Hiraya Nobori] Tomomi-chan Kiki Ippatsu | Tomomi-chan's Close Call (COMIC LO 2015-11) [English] [alparslan]
[Ponsuke] Kataguruma (COMIC LO 2020-05) [English] [Digital]
[Himeno Mikan] Doctor Fish (COMIC LO 2015-06) [English] {Mistvern}
[Yuzu Machi] Obenkyou Yori Ochinchin ga Suki! | I Love Dick More Than Studying! (Digital Puni Pedo! Vol. 09) [English] [Tenua]
[Noise] Kodomo no Ecchi wa Ippo Zutsu | Children Learn About Sex One Step at a Time (Oppai, Futomomo, Sokoni Short Pants) [English] [The Chrysanthemum Translations] [Digital]
[Takaoka Motofumi] Omiyage Natsu Imouto | Souvenir Summer Sister (COMIC LO 2018-11) [English] [Shippoyasha] [Digital]

Honorable mentions - 2
[MonsieuR (MUK)] Tiny Evil chans! 2 -Mujaki de Zankoku na Shoujo-tachi no Ecchi na Tanpenshuu- [English] [Digital]
[EB110SS] Tama ni Dorobou!? | Being a Thief sometimes is a Good Thing!? (Ratte Suki Nanramon) [English] [Brook09 + Mehiel] ++Also Least Unrealistic++

Cunny is rarely used, the cunny list consisting of only 21 works in the Total Loli list, 22 if "Tiny Evil chans! 2" is counted despite being disqualified for being made up of two stories under 11 pages. 1.73%-1.81% of lolicon hentai. Two galleries with particularly high usage of the word are:
"My Actual Daughter Is 11 Year Old, Grade-Schooler Idol, Yusa Kozue", which said cunny 15 times
"Being a Thief sometimes is a Good Thing!?" which said cunny 9 times

Translation Group Xood used "cunny" so heavily it bothered people, so they stopped and left "RIP CunnyGate" in the translation credits of several galleries after this. Despite this their few translations using the word did not have a particularly high amount of usage, they worked on neither of the two mentioned high usage galleries.



Miscellaneous
Tanks, Magazines, and Anthologies
Digital Puni Pedo is a series of anthologies. It's first issue was released in September 2016 and it's 18th volume was released last August 2020. The total pages of all volumes is over 1900 pages over 4 years. Saying the average story is around 20 pages, that's 95 stories labelled as part of the Digital Puni Pedo series. Digital Puni Pedo entries make up 16 works listed in Loli Total, 1.32%. The majority, 12, are in the WW category.

Heartcatch Puni Pedo! Cosmos Gumi is a 183 page anthology. Only 1 story within it is part of the Loli Total, and is in the category Least Unrealistic WW.
Puni Pedo!! Sono 2 Sakura Gumi is a 179 page anthology. Only 1 story within it is part of the Loli Total, and is in the category Very Unrealistic
Happiness Charge Puni Pedo! Koume Gumi is a 167 page anthology. It is not included in any of the lists.
Smile Puni Pedo! Himawari-gumi is a 184 Page anthology. It is not included in any of the lists.
Puni Pedo!! is a 180 page anthology. It is not included in any of the lists.

I think it is likely all these Puni Pedo anthologies are done under the same publisher.

Gekisatsu! JS Collection is a 202 page tankoubon by Maka Fushigi. 4 stories within it are part of the Loli Total. None are in the WW category, but 3 are in the Least Unrealistic category
JC's Trip is a 203 page tankoubon by Suzuki Kyoutarou. Only 1 story within it is part of the Loli Total, and is in the category Least Unrealistic WW..
Pure Puri Children is a 199 page tankoubon by Fujisaka Lyric, and is fully translated by Mistvern. Only 1 story within it is part of the Loli Total, and is in the category Very Unrealistic.
Pedou is 196 page tankoubon by Minion. It is not included in any of the lists.

Little Girl Kiss is the name of two different tankoubons. Little Girl Kiss by Chakura Kazuhiko has 197 pages. Only 1 story within it is part of the Loli Total, and is in the category Least Unrealistic. Little Girl Kiss by Ouya Onoaki has 197 pages. It was not included in any lists, but is fully translated by Mistvern. A cursory glance shows the majority of stories within it have strong fantasy elements.

Really miscellaneous
Many lolicon works, particularly those in the WW category, like to use the phrase "adult dick/penis/cock" a lot as an indirect way of emphasizing the girl is a child. There's also significant focus on how "hot", figuratively and literally, the higher body temperature of a child is.

Hatsumi Ryomoto is a chick who draws lots of high quality loli, even yuri, and that's hot. Why a Plain Glasses-Girl like Me Started Wearing Sexy Panties will always be a favorite of mine.

RIP Yasuda. May you follow up that To Be Continued in the next life.
Rustle and PTHC
God I hope this term isn't filtered because that would fuck my shit right up.
This information may make some uncomfortable, though some may see it as no worse than Fuchur's knowledge and use of Laura B in Unteralterbach, I feel it goes a step farther. It was mentioned in the GR8 DEB8 thread ages ago that there were claims of an in-crowd pedophile term in one of Rustle's Doujinshi on the socks of one of his lolis. This is something I would have never noticed had I not first been told, since his lolis have graphic socks all the time. But here it is, in big clear letters, in both English and the raws. Lolicon Special, the first one, has PTHC written on the girl's socks right on the cover page. This is no accident, that would be a 1 in 456976 chance based on a limit of four English characters alone. Some of you reading this may have noticed on occasion the CP links spammed on the webring would often include the term PTHC. From what I've gathered looking into this, PTHC is an acronym similar to CP, but more severe. I don't know the exact words it stands for are, but that it definitely refers to hardcore CP. Not barely legal creep shots, not shady modelling companies pushing the line of legality like Laura B of UAB fame, not self recorded videos by retarded teenagers masturbating, but actual hardcore shit. This suggests Rustle is in possession of and a consumer of such materials. Given possession of CP wasn't illegal in Japan until 2015, and Lolicon Special was uploaded to the Panda in 2011, I'd say it's very likely. That alone may be enough to turn people away from his works, and many away from supporting him financially given what he may likely use that money for. But I have yet still more unsettling things to suggest. Rustle's art is very high quality, and I'd say save for the anime heads, his anatomy is very on point and consistent. He's able to draw manko very well as well. It would not surprise me to find that his work references, or even to some degree traces, CP he has. This is of course, not concrete evidence, but there's a fair chance of it, which is more than can be said for 99% of all other lolicon artists. Thinking on this, I'm reminded of something I once read a long time ago, that Rustle doesn't much like doing loli, but does it because it's profitable. I thought at the time, "Why doesn't he draw something else then? His art is amazing!" Given this new context, it's not unreasonable to think this dislike may stem from guilt or witnessing unpleasant things for the sake of making his drawings earn more money by depicting accurately something that can't be gotten with (currently) legal references, the deformation of an underage vagina. But what do I know? I'm just an autist who reads too much loli.
 

immahnoob

varishangout.com
Regular
Patron of the Forums
Holy fuck, this is a great way to get good artists. Thanks /b/ anon, your autism is well received here!
I'll be going through these lists on realism to see if I agree with them as well.
 

cunny poster

varishangout.com
Regular
Holy fuck, this is a great way to get good artists. Thanks /b/ anon, your autism is well received here!
I'll be going through these lists on realism to see if I agree with them as well.
Ikr, I've been going through it like they're reccomends and his ratings are pretty accurate so far,
 
Top